Punchdrunk with cuts?

Closures and cutbacks seem to be coming thick and fast at present. So much so that there is a danger that communities feel there is so much happening that it’s difficult to know where to start.

Nurseries have taken a ‘hit’ with two proposed for closure in Edinburgh East – High School Yards in the city centre and Princess Elizabeth in Prestonfield.  And now a third nursery in the west of the city is also to close, ‘officially’ on health and safety grounds but as my colleague Andrew Burns, leader of the Labour Group on the council has pointed out, the Lib Dem/SNP Council administration included savings amounting to closure of 3 nurseries in their budget in February 2010.  It seems highly convenient that a nursery like Westfield Court which has been running for 60 years is now deemed ‘unsafe’ because it is where it has always been – on the top floor of a block of flats.

Westfield Court is one of the very few ‘multi storey’ blocks in Britain which actually included a facility like this. Many of the early proponents of multi storey living had the vision that these buildings would be more than just houses and would have this sort of community facility. It’s sad to see it go on the ground of ‘health and safety’.

I noticed in the newspapers that some of the Westfield Court parents were alleging that the number of places had been ‘run down’ recently.  One type of place that seems to be going is full day (9 – 3) places.  One constituent of mine very recently contacted me because she had (after a period of several months in temporary accommodation following relationship breakdown) finally been offered a house, but one which was quite far away from the nursery where her child had been given a full day place to provide the mother with assistance with health issues.  Asking whether there could be a similar place found nearer the new home she was told there were none. As it happens the ‘new home’ was just around the corner from Westfield Court and I had suggested to her (before last week’s announcement) that she should ask about this as a possibility.

High School Yards nursery

High School Yards nursery

I suspect this running down of places is also affecting High School Yards and Princess Elizabeth making it easier to ‘justify’ closure.  Before the summer holidays I was approached by parents from St Leonard’s nursery school because places were being cut there, including both ‘free’ and ‘paid for’ full time places.

I have a special affection for High School Yards because two of my children attended there. I know it has received praise in inspections and has flourished despite its ‘city centre’ location. Hints of Westfield Court came in the announcement about High School Yards also with the Council saying that the ‘internal layout’ was unsuitable – despite having served generations of children very well.